What’s Better for Long-Term Weight Loss? Lap-Band® Vs Gastric Sleeves

Last Updated : May 30, 2024

If you’ve been considering weight-loss surgery, you’ll have noticed by now that there is more
than one route to follow to achieve your desired results.

Both Lap-Band® and gastric sleeves are standard solutions for long-term weight loss, but
how do you figure out which option is best for you?

When deciding between gastric sleeves and the Lap-Band, it’s best to look at the big picture.
You want to examine not just the short-term success of the surgery but how it will impact
your life in the long run.

There are many similarities between the two procedures and in both operations, a surgeon
alters the size of the stomach so that it will hold less food leading to weight loss, as well as
better physical and mental health.

With bariatric procedures like the gastric sleeve, patients tend to lose weight rapidly in the
months following their surgery, but this isn’t always indicative of long-term success.

On the other hand, weight loss occurs slower with the Lap-Band, but patients will experience
unique advantages of this procedure over time.

We compared the long-term weight loss results of gastric sleeves and Lap-Band against one
another to help you make an informed decision about which option is best for you.

Research On 10-Year Success Rates Of the Lap-Band

A study carried out over a 10-year period proved insightful in determining the long-term
success of each surgery. Those who participated in the study had their weight-loss journey
examined one year, 5 years, and 10 years post-surgery.

Long term weight loss success

The study found that participants with a gastric sleeve had more rapid and significant weight
loss at the one and five-year marks.

However, at the ten-year mark, the research found that weight-loss results were comparable
between both groups. This means that the long-term success of the gastric sleeve and the
Lap-Band procedure is about the same.

Is Lap-Band Surgery Right for Me?

As the long-term success of a Lap-Band and the gastric sleeve is the same, it can be
challenging to determine which route to take. Your decision will likely come from your
personal circumstances and health requirements.

The gastric sleeve may be the more appealing route as you see results faster, but it’s
essential to understand that Lap-Bands offer many unique advantages. Let’s take a look at
some of them.

The benefits of getting a Lap-Band

They adjust to your body’s needs

Change within our bodies is constant. The Lap-Band adjusts to these changes as they
happen. Unlike gastric sleeves, the Lap-Band can be easily tightened or loosened via a port
under the skin.

This means they can be loosened during pregnancy, allowing for more significant portions
of food if needed.

The Lap-Band is less invasive than gastric sleeves

During the procedure, no stomach cutting, or rerouting of the organs occurs. A gastric sleeve
procedure removes around 80% of the stomach.

The Lap-Band is also not permanent – if you change your mind later down the line, the
surgery is easily reversible. The Lap-Band is the only bariatric surgery that’s reversible.

They don’t have negative effects on your body’s vitamin absorption

A gastric sleeve is considered a malabsorptive surgery. When the intestines are shortened
during the procedure, it results in fewer nutrients being absorbed by the body. Patients who
undergo a gastric sleeve often require an extensive supplement routine.

Lap-Band patients are not at risk of malabsorption, and any nutrient deficiencies from eating
smaller meals can be amended with a multivitamin.

The Lap-Band has a faster recovery rate

Lap-Band surgery generally takes less than an hour, and most patients are in and out of the
hospital on the same day. The procedure is minimally invasive, with a surgeon making
between one to five minor surgical cuts in the abdomen.

Many patients can return to their regular daily routine a couple of days after surgery. After six
weeks, patients can resume a normal, balanced diet. Overall, Lap-Band surgery has a much
faster recovery time than more invasive bariatric procedures.

Long-term Benefits of Lap-Band Surgery in Ireland

Lap-Band procedures offer the same fantastic health benefits as the more invasive gastric
sleeve approach to weight loss. Apart from altering a person’s physical appearance and
helping their self-esteem, the benefits of the Lap-Band on the body include:

  • Long-term remission for type 2 diabetes
  • Improved cardiovascular health
  • Relief of depression
  • Eliminate obstructive sleep apnea
  • Joint-pain relief
  • Improve fertility
  • Prevent pregnancy complications

Hopefully, you now understand the differences between the Lap-Band and gastric sleeves
and are in a better position to decide what’s best for your body.

If you decide the Lap-Band is the right surgical weight-loss option for you, then the team
Auralia would love to help.

You’ll be in good hands under the care of our experienced team who have many years of
experience performing bariatric surgery in Ireland. Get in touch with our team today to book
a consultation

Explore More Articles